Apple “Just Works” don’t you know *sic*…

April 8, 2008 on 7:18 pm | In Uncategorized | By BioHazard |

I’ve liked Apple for a couple years after I started working with them full-time. It was leagues better than the Micromess I left for it. Unfortunately, now the Apple system is slipping into eviality. I’m having a terrible time keeping things working. Whenever something can go wrong, it does. You think I’m making it up don’t you? Here’s some examples:

  • I needed to set up a voice chat with iChat. Can I use my nice headset? Nope. The iMacs only have a line-in jack. Great. I know the iMac has a built-in mic, but I want to use /mine/. Next, I wanted to extend it to video. Of course if I was stupid, I could go buy an iSight camera that costs as much as a full digicam. I bought a Logitech camera. It said “MacOS” on the box. I plug it in, nothing. I had to install a funky Linux driver port to get it to work with Skype, it wasn’t 1337 enough to work with iChat. iChat sucks anyway so meh.
  • Okay, what else? I have a G5 XServe with OSX Server 10.4 and a Opteron server running Gentoo Linux. I wanted to backup the XServe to the Linux server. since it has more room (the XServe only has 200GB even with all 3 drives striped!). Can I use RSyncd? No. SSHFS? Nope. NFS? No. FT-freaking-P? Really really no. I didn’t even bother with Samba as there are tons of UNIX native solutions that claim to be supported by OSX.
  • I’m one to like a clean network as far as traffic goes. Why do all the Macs need to use ZeroConf/Bonjour/Redevouz/MDNS/Avahi/wtfbbq? I have a fully functional DNS system. I don’t want anything to be able to subvert my DNS system with MNDS. Also, what’s with all the SMB boradcast messages when I have Windows sharing turned off? There are no SMB-capable devices in the building. Same with AppleTalk. WTF is Appletalk doing in any modern OS? AppleTalk is long dead, rotten, made into gasoline and burned. MacOS doesn’t work with anything older than a couple years anyway so why bother looking for such old stuff?
  • Another thing that bothers me is the inability of iTunes/QuickTime to play any free audio/video formats. The Apple web page on OSX says clearly “We support Open Standards” (it even has a picture of a “come on in” sign *sic*), but it can’t play Vorbis, XviD, Theora, FLAC, hell I wouldn’t be surprised if it couldn’t play WAVs…
  • MacOS X 10.4 has a cool new remote desktop service that lets you connect to the Mac and do remote stuff. Not sure why it took them so long but whatever. Anyway, they advertise that it works with VNC clients as well. Lies! I was really looking forward to this feature. Sad was I when no VNC client I tried worked from my Linux machines. I did manage to get Chicken of the VNC to work, but the server will only let it connect with /zero/ bandwidth-saving capability. That sucks. If I have to be on the local network, why not just be at my computer?
  • I do have to say, AirPort works really well. It “Just Works” with every network gear that gets near it. Like some cheap ho it will associate and …exchange…packets… with anything that beacons. Eww.
  • Apple is clearly in bed with Microsoft. Every version of MacOS since 10.3 comes bundled with an “Office 200x Test Drive”. First of all, I object to putting cocaine in birthday party goody bags, but that aside, the Office uninstaller should work. Upon running it, you get a wizard that seaches for Office, tells you it’s going to remove it and grays out the “continue” button. Big help that is. $ shred -r /Applications/Microsoft* takes care of that problem though.

Last week I got some Leopard machines. Lot’s of “Just Work”ing here:

  • The MS Office uninstaller is /still/ broken after what, 5 years?
  • Adobe CS2 is really, really unstable. Bad stuff. I really wish I had known that.
  • Searches with spotlight do not work when searching Server 10.4 shares. (the Apple tech basically said “Go buy 10.5 server. ($1,000)”)
  • Our font collection had to be hacked pretty radically to work with inDesign on 10.5.
  • The printers can no longer print through anything but the first tray and nothing but letter size paper.
  • It doesn’t want to accept the address to my local NTP server.
  • The most annoying 10.5 problem of all: Firefox is severely broken. It can’t browse much of anything and all file downloads fail. Safari works great. It just doesn’t have any of my mission-critical plug-ins I need to do my job (Web Developer, FireBug, Tamper Data, etc).
  • This is only after 1 day of toying with 10.5. I expect more problems once the production department starts doing real work on these machines

Anyway, that’s just what I can remember off the top of my head. I’ve had countless problems with things not working with the Apple system. Basically if you want it to work with a mac, the device itself must have an apple logo pressed or etched into it. The bigger the logo, the better it works. All that “Apple Just Works” stuff is a bunch of hooey. Don’t drink the Kool-Aid. It will go right through you and get you in the end.

At this point, there aren’t as many dart holes in my picture of Jobs as there are in Ballmer, but there are some really good shots.

9 Comments »

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

  1. I could have a *huge* rebuttal (Q is probably thinking “Oh, it’s ON!)

    I will refute the Quicktime claim however. Open Standards….”standards”. Last I checked neither Ogg nor FLAC were standards. I believe MPEG is, however.

    I guess what I’ll say in general is no operating system is perfect. Mac OS X “just works” for exactly the things it is designed and marketed to do. And most of your points are moot with Leopard anyway (and don’t give me that “but its not in Tiger”… it wasn’t in System 7 either!)

    Comment by jason — April 8, 2008 #

  2. Apple isn’t that great, anyway. Maybe if they stopped lying their butts off like Microsoft (Linux does -not- and will -never- steal their source code!) and started doing their jobs (like making stuff work and compatible) they would be a lot better than the competetion (and make the error prompts worth a crap and less frequent.).

    Comment by Shadow — April 8, 2008 #

  3. …And I’m pretty sure MPEG isn’t a standard, just another format.

    Comment by Shadow — April 8, 2008 #

  4. iTunes seems to have a phobia of playing anything that isn’t in the proper format. If mplayer can play just about everything, then why can’t a multimillion/billion internation corp get something that will at least play a few different formats? What about when I add a video to my library, and try to use my iPod, does it not encode it for me?

    Comment by QBasicer — April 9, 2008 #

  5. This is where techies totally miss the mark.. Of course MPlayer can play a buttload of formats. iTunes can’t. There are about 400 million copies of iTunes out there. How many users do you think give anything remotely close to a shit about that? You want a some magical format? Use MPlayer.

    iTunes does what it’s designed to do exceptionally well. So does Mac OS X. If you push it to your technological needs, sure you will find shortcomings. Would you like me to a hundred^H^H^H^H^H^H couple flaws of Linux? I could. But the truth is Linux does it’s job well. Away from the desktop.

    Comment by jason — April 10, 2008 #

  6. Comment by jason — April 10, 2008 #

  7. So, you’re blindly taking the word of… Wikipedia, of all things… as fact. Fascinating. I said I was “pretty sure”, not “I’m certain”. But, if you’re going to be mean about it, how about using a CREDIBLE source to put it to rest?

    Shadow

    Comment by Shadow — April 11, 2008 #

  8. If you push it [Mac OS] to your technological needs, sure you will find shortcomings.

    “push it”? FTP is pushing the technological limits? Man, when did I get transported back to the 80’s?

    Would you like me to a hundred^H^H^H^H^H^H couple flaws of Linux?

    Hell I could find that many myself, but Linux doesn’t cost $399 per system and the Linux distro makers don’t promise anything about stability or compatibility.

    Oh, and about your screenshot: QuickTime can’t play MPEG4; DivX, XviD, not even a VOB I had lying around. I had to install VLC.


    Don’t worry though, as long as there are devotees like you around, Apple will never go out of business and can continue to provide mediocre software to users all over the world.

    Comment by BioHazard — April 11, 2008 #

  9. Naw, not trying to be mean, just trying to illustrate a point. You’ll notice the wikipedia article is sourced, too. But again, just for illustrations.

    Last time I checked the client version of OS X ran for 129, and the server ran for 999$ for unlimited. I’m probably wrong on that last price though… Quicktime has had native Mpeg4 support since at least Tiger, you can take that one to the bank.

    I don’t know, I am a devotee but only because I find their software to be better than the alternatives. I really don’t think Windows or Linux is better, at all. Not for my uses certainly (I’m not a server admin though. I would say linux is likely more suited for that). Mac OS X is not flawless, I know that. Nothing is. But it’s great for me.

    Comment by jason — April 12, 2008 #

Leave a comment

XHTML: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Powered by WordPress with Pool theme design by Borja Fernandez. I rewrote the CSS because I'm cool like that.
Entries and comments feeds. Valid XHTML and CSS. ^Top^